Home / Categories / Crimes / The Boy in the Box

The Boy in the Box

Photo of the Boy in the Box

Photo of the Boy in the Box

Known also as “America’s Unknown Child”, the “Boy in the Box”  murder has gone unsolved since the discovery of his body on  25 February 1957.

On that fateful day, an anxious college student, Frederick Benosis, reported finding the nude body of what appeared to be a young boy, 4 to 6 years old, wrapped in a flannel blanket inside a discarded baby’s bassinet cardboard box distributed by the JC Penny store.

This wasn’t the first discovery of the boy.  Two days prior, a young man spotted the body when he was checking on his muskrat traps in this rural area.  Knowing his muskrat traps were illegal, he decided against telling the police.  It was only a few days later that Benosis came across the body.  He waited an additional day before contacting the authorities because he was in the area spying on young women at the Good Shepherd School and was worried about telling the police why he was there.

Local media was fixated on this case.  Pictures of the young boy were plastered everywhere, including flyers and gas bills for the Philadelphia customers.

Two photos of the unknown boy dressed in typical children's clothing. An attempt by detectives to make him "more recognizable".

Photo of the unknown boy dressed in typical children’s clothing. An attempt by detectives to make him “more recognizable”.

The boy’s identity has never been determined and the case has yet to be solved.  The boy was described as having blue eyes, fair complexion and medium to light brown, crudely cut hair.  His nails were noted as being neatly trimmed.  He had deep bruises covering much of the his body and face and experts speculate that due to the cold weather, the child may have been lying in that box between 2-3 days to 2 to 3 weeks.

Initial thoughts were promising, as police were sure that someone would report a missing child or that his photograph distributed throughout the area would lead to the identity of the child and the murderer.  But this never occurred.  Nobody reported a missing child that fit his description and the thousands of leads produced came to a dead end.

Investigators focused on the baby bassinet box that the boy was found in.  It was one of 12 sold by a JC Penny store in Upper Darby.  All but one were traced back to their owners.  Even the boy’s fingerprints and footprints came up negative  when they were compared to a national database and local hospital records.

The Evidence

  • The boys hair was crudely cut and located throughout his body, indicating it was cut while he was deceased and naked or immediately before he died.
  • His hands and feet were wrinkled indicating they were submerged in water for an extended time just before or after he died.
  • The child may have had a chronic eye ailment
  • He had not eaten 2-3 hours before death.
  • The faded cheap flannel blanket he was wrapped in was made in either North Carolina or Quebec, Canada.  It was also massed produced and shipped to multiple locations.
  • His esophagus contained a dark, brown residue, possibly indicating he vomited shortly before death.
  • He was severely malnourished.
  • Cause of death was multiple blows to the head.

The boy was buried in a potters field next to Mechanicsville and Dunks Ferry Rd, the tombstone simply read “Heavenly Father, Bless This Unknown Boy”.  Eventually, the boy’s body was exhumed in 1998 and mitochondrial DNA was extracted from his tooth.  Efforts are currently underway to link this child to a relative by scanning it through  a database.  However, the mitochondrial DNA sequence is too small to produce a conclusive match with anyone.

On 11 November 1998, the boy was reburied in a donated coffin at the Ivy Hill cemetery and a website was launched to keep this boy’s memory alive and to help generate new leads.  The website is America’s Unknown Child.

The possibility of this 53 year old crime being solved is quickly vanishing.  The case remains open in name only.  The  police officers and investigators who tried to keep this case moving forward are passing away, or too old to continue pursuing the occasional lead that comes their way.  Chances are that the individual or individuals who killed this young boy have since died and will never face justice for their crime.

Experts agree that if this case occurred 10 or 20 years ago, the crime most likely would have been solved.  In 1957, police departments did not communicate or share information outside of their local areas.  Media coverage was also limited to the Pennsylvania/Delaware area.  In today’s age, this case would have been national news and the information pertaining to this case would have been available to all city and federal law enforcement agencies.

About Jim Heddlesten

Jim Heddlesten
Jim was born and raised in Naples, Italy. He created this website in December 2009 because of his fondness for historical mysteries. Since creating the website, Historic Mysteries has grown incredibly fast and over 300 mysteries are now documented on this site. Thank you for visiting and please bookmark this site.

3 comments

  1. i have read like 200 things about him and i want to make a club to help. but im only 12. so i need alot of people to make a difference. i hope we find out who he is at least.

  2. dude this is sad, but it has to be the father or someone in the foster home, ive recently read that someone who was at that home during that time said there were alot of videos tooken, hopefuly they will find them and this case will be solved. when i get older im gonna try to solve this case.

  3. this is sad i no one came forward and said anything who he was or nothing R.I.P buddy you will always be in my heart

Leave a Reply